Named after its founder, a wealthy contractor named Richard Carman, Carmanville’s exact boundaries are a little unclear.
According to Phelps’ New-York City Guide, published in 1853:
“This is a pleasant village, situated upon the rising ground, on the Hudson River, in the vicinity of Fort Washington.”
Another reference, The Tree Bore Fruit, about nearby Manhattan College and published in 1953, puts Carmenville a good 28 blocks south at 155th Street.
[NYPL postcard of 155th and Amsterdam Avenue in 1917—the remains of Carmanville?]
And according to a 1914 New York Times article, a Carmanville Park once was located at Amsterdam Avenue and 152nd Street.
Still another Times article, published in 2004 to commemorate the opening of the New York City subway, has Carmanville at 125th Street.
Tags: Carmanville Fort Washington, Carmanville NYC, Carmanville Upper West Side, Hersensville, New York City street, old Manhattan neighborhoods, Phelps' New-York City Guide, Piggery District, Richard Carman, Upper West Side history