How corrupt? He was in on a notorious plot to kidnap and assassinate George Washington.
This crazy idea naturally came about in a tavern, a place called Corbie’s, near Washington’s residence. All those involved were sworn to secrecy.
But someone squealed, and at 1 a.m. on June 22, 1776, Patriot troops surrounded Matthews’ Flatbush home and brought him to jail.
Though the plot was real (one of Washington’s guards was hanged for it, and New York governor William Tryon was involved), there wasn’t enough evidence to charge Matthews—who resumed his mayoral duties until 1783.
After the war, Matthews apparently confessed. “I formed a plan for the taking of Mr. Washington and his Guard prisoners but which was not effected,” he told a royal commission in London.
Interestingly, this didn’t stop him from getting his name on a Bronx park: Matthews Muliner Playground. Even the Parks Department identifies him as a thief, kidnap plotter, and embezzler.
[Right: New York in 1776, from the NYPL]
Tags: British loyalists New York City, corrupt New York City mayors, David Matthews, George Washington in New York City, kidnap George Washington, Matthews Muliner Playground, New York City Revolutionary War, New York mayor David Matthews, William Tryon