A weird, popular sport in 19th century New York

Lots of today’s sports built their fan base in the late 19th century, like baseball, tennis, and cycling. But none of these had the city cheering nearly as hard as a forgotten competitive activity called pedestrianism.


A form of race walking, pedestrianism “spawned America’s first celebrity athletes, the forerunners—forewalkers, actually—of LeBron James and Tiger Woods,” wrote Matthew Algeo in his book, Pedestrianism.

Pedestrianismbrooklyneagle1867“The top pedestrians earned a fortune in prize money and endorsement deals . . . their images appeared on some of the first cigarette trading cards, which children collected as avidly as later generations would collect baseball cards.”

Pedestrianism boomed after the industrial revolution and the standardization of the workweek gave millions of middle class New Yorkers leisure time, something once available only to the rich.

The idea that the masses needed rest and relaxation, specifically in nature, had also gained popularity, particularly after the Civil War.


Parks were built, the seashore became a place of enjoyment, and ordinary people flocked to watch competitive walking the way millions of Americans watch Sunday football today.

Pedestrianism was pretty rough. Long-distance events involved walking hundreds of miles between cities. Madison Square Garden hosted six-day races (competitors walked for 21 hours, then slept for three) that drew thousands of spectators, stated Kerry Segrave’s America on Foot.


One pedestrian star, Edward Payson Weston (above), would enter a roller rink and “attempt to walk 100 miles in 24 hours,” Algeo said via a 2014 interview with NPR. “And people would pay 10 cents just to come and watch him walk in circles for a day.”

The sport’s heyday stretched through the 1870s and 1880s, then died down as the bicycle became safer and other sports stole away fans. But not before a pedestrianism revival was attempted.

TheGildedAgeinNewYorkcover“More than 20 years ago the craze for affairs of this sort was at its height, but the novelty of the thing soon wore off and the sport was relegated to the oblivion that its absurdity and uselessness so richly merited,” sneered the Brooklyn Daily Eagle in 1902.

The rise in leisure time in New York after the Civil War spawned a sports craze in the metropolis, covered more extensively with terrific images in The Gilded Age in New York, 1870-1910.

[Top photo: NPR; second image: Brooklyn Daily Eagle, 1867; third photo: NPR; fourth image: New York Times, 1874]

Tags: , , , , ,

9 Responses to “A weird, popular sport in 19th century New York”

  1. Rich T Says:

    Was the guy’s name in the newspaper article “One Butt”???

    • Nido Says:

      No, “one” is capitalized only because it starts the sentence. It refers to someone (last?)named Butt.

  2. Force Tube Avenue Says:

    Hi, I had no idea about “Pedestrians” as professional athletes; most interesting. I am very curious about the location of the “Hall of the American Institute”, given at 63rd Street and 6th Avenue. That spot is well inside the confines of Central Park. Could a building have remained with the park around it for a time?

  3. ephemeralnewyork Says:

    Hi Force Tube, that’s an early New York Times typo! This NYPL stereoscopic image places the American Institute at 63rd Street and Third Avenue:


    About One Butt, I have no idea what that refers to…but it’s now my favorite nickname for slow walkers.

  4. Jerry Slaff Says:

    Excellent book by Algeo, by the way. Pick it up.

  5. Paul B Says:

    Interesting – there was a tradition of pedestrianism on the other side of the Atlantic too. A couple of posts that might be of interest, the second of which seems to have competed in New York at the end of his career.

  6. PSM Says:


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: