New York City has hundreds of breathtaking residential streets that inspire beauty—and deep real-estate envy.
But perhaps the first “block beautiful,” as it was called by a home design magazine around 1909, is the stretch of East 19th Street between Irving Place and Third Avenue.
The houses here were largely built in the 1850s—two decades after real estate man Samuel Ruggles bought land on a marsh-turned-farm called by the old Dutch name “crommesshie” and remade it into Gramercy Park.
Yet 19th Street’s eclectic charm comes in part from architect Frederick Sterner, who remodeled many of the original houses in the early 1900s, starting with his own at number 139 (left).
Sterner altered traditional brownstones, considered dour by the turn of the century, into more fashionable residences with playful touches like light colors, wide shutters, jockey statues, stucco facades, and colored tiles.
His alterations earned high-fives from architectural critics and attracted painters and actors, turning the block into something of an artists’ colony in the 1920s and 1930s.
One of those artists was social realist painter George Bellows, who moved his family into number 146 (right) closer to the Third Avenue end of the block and built an attic studio.
Bellows was known to paint scenes of Gramercy Park, like this one from 1920 with his kids in the center.
Painter and muralist Robert Winthrop Chanler lived across from Bellows at number 147, the wide and pretty home with the whimsical giraffe panels over the entrances (left).
They mimic the giraffes in one of Chanler’s murals, from 1922.
Tudor-style number 132 (below), built by Sterner, has an illustrious list of former tenants, including muckraking author Ida Tarbull and painter Cecilia Beaux.
Some well-known actresses also reportedly lived in this apartment building in the middle of the block: Helen Hayes, Lillian Gish, Ethel Barrymore, and Theda Bara.
Of course, no New York City block beautiful would be complete without renovated carriage houses, and this pocket of East 19th Street has three.
The two neighbor stables at numbers 127 and 129 (below) near Irving Place may have been built as early as the 1860s.
Their red brick and Gothic touches make them look like they belong in a fairy tale.
And then there’s teeny tiny number 124, also on the end close to Irving Place, which comes off as a holdover from the colonial Dutch era (below).
This Flemish-inspired carriage house actually only dates to the late 19th century and for most of its history has been a residence.
Ephemeral New York 
