In a neighborhood known for its charming brownstone-lined streets, St. Luke’s Place in the West Village stands out as exceptionally magical.
Built in the early 1850s opposite a sprawling cemetery owned by Trinity Church, the 15 rowhouses span the north side of this slightly curved lane—which is actually Leroy Street, rechristened between Seventh Avenue and Hudson Street to give the block cachet.
The first owners of these impressive homes, with their roomy parlors and grand entrances, were wealthy merchants.
By the 1910s and 1920s, like so much else in the Village, many were carved into flats and taken over by painters and writers. These newcomers gave St. Luke’s Place its literary and artistic reputation.
The roster of one-time residents features some diverse talent. Painter Paul Cadmus (above) lived at 5 St. Luke’s Place (left, with number 6 in 1939).
Number 11 (below in 1900, with 12 and 13) was home to Max Eastman, poet and publisher of the anarchist periodical The Masses.
Sherwood Anderson resided in a one-room basement flat at number 12. Theodore Dreiser took an apartment at number 16 a month later (bottom photo, center) and began An American Tragedy there.
Poet Marianne Moore (left, in the 1920s in the Village) and her mother lived two doors down in the basement of number 14.
The location was convenient, as Moore worked in the public library built across the street after the cemetery was moved and the land turned into a city park.
St. Luke’s had other notable residents: sculptor Theodore Roszak kept his studio at number 1. Jazz Age mayor Jimmy Walker had his family home at number 6. West Side Story playwright Arthur Laurents owned number 9.
And as 1980s TV fans know, number 10 was used to represent the exterior of the Huxtable family home on The Cosby Show.
St. Luke’s is as lovely as ever, and if it’s still home to many poets and painters, they keep a low profile. As for the ones who resided here in the 1920s and 1930s, if only we knew more about how their lives overlapped as neighbors.
[Second and third photos: MCNY; Paul Cadmus painting by Luigi Lucioni, Brooklyn Museum]
Tags: artists and writers Greenwich Village, literary Greenwich Village, Luke's, Marianne Moore St, Most Beautiful Street in Greenwich Village, New York in the 1920s, Sherwood Anderson St. Luke's, St. Luke's Place Greenwich Village, Theodore Dreiser St. Luke's, West Village alleys
Ephemeral New York 
December 11, 2017 at 6:47 am |
[…] Midwestern transplant who moved to Gotham in 1894 to pursue a literary career. He himself lived in shabby apartments as he worked as a journalist, writing short prose pieces like this holiday-themed piece that gave a […]
June 28, 2018 at 2:13 am |
[…] Midwestern transplant who moved to Gotham in 1894 to pursue a literary career. He himself lived in shabby apartments as he worked as a journalist, writing short prose pieces like this holiday-themed piece that gave a […]
March 7, 2019 at 5:16 am |
Starting in the 1920s, My Great Aunt by marriage, Alice Nelson Smith owned the house with her husband, the portrait and mural painter Duncan Smith. She was an artist in her own right and had her own fashion line at Lord and Taylor. Also, the movie @wait Until Dark”, starring Audrey Hepburn, was filmed there.
April 21, 2020 at 10:28 pm |
Lisa, I’m writing a proposal about Modernist teachers at the University of Virginia. Would like to discuss Duncan Smith with you.